Improving the critique system

Hello !

I think the critique system could use a significant improvement to liven up the site a bit.
The three icons encouraging weekly critiques are rather useless. It would be great if every time we complete three critiques, we had the opportunity to post one of our drawings for the community to react to. This wouldn't render the subscription system useless and would re-energize the community.
Such a reward would make the community more vibrant and prevent it from always being the same people, haha.

This is a great idea! :)

Yeah, I think that's a greater idea!

Hello guys,

Particular examples might be added to the critique system to improve constructive criticism. Giving examples may help provide context and direction, which makes criticisms easier to implement for better results.

That idea was good. but why removed?

I'm not sure what you mean about it being removed? It was never implemented, or at least not yet.

I think that user deleted their account themselves. The OG post is from almost 2 years ago. What happened in between would be anyone's guess.

Great suggestions, Encouraging more thoughtful critiques with a simple reward system could really boost community engagement. A guideline or template for giving constructive feedback would also help new users. A short trial period could show how well this approach works.

I like the idea of rewarding users for giving thoughtful critiques. Another option could be earning critique points that can be exchanged for benefits like highlighting a drawing, unlocking additional community feedback requests, or temporary profile badges. It would encourage consistent participation while keeping the focus on providing helpful, high quality feedback.

I like the idea of rewarding users for giving thoughtful critiques. Another option could be earning critique points that can be exchanged for benefits like highlighting a drawing, unlocking additional community feedback requests, or temporary profile badges. It would encourage consistent participation while keeping the focus on providing helpful, high quality feedback.