給予良好的批評

何時進行批判

有人要求您批評他們的工作嗎?哇!這一定意味著他們認為您才華橫溢,聰明並且周圍是美好的。對你好!但是請堅持!儘管如此,請不要自動說“是”。

要求您批評的人是一個積極希望改善工作的人。他們可能會致力於練習,以改善您指出的問題領域。如果您說“是”,然後想不出任何有用的話,所以您只需隨機交談並嘗試說要說的話,您可以將它們發送給他們狂野的鵝來追逐浪費的練習。更糟糕的是,您可能會產生負面影響,並通過阻止這種勤奮的靈魂來造成更大的浪費。只有在您準備接受說一些有用的責任的責任時,只有同意提出批評。如果您想不出有用的話,請原諒。

何時提出批評的另一個重要的經驗法則:如果沒有特別要求,請不要提供批判。是的,藝術家可能會做任何錯誤的事情,您知道解決它的理想方法,但是如果他們沒有準備好接受批評,那麼您所要做的就是驚訝和激怒他們。您越難讓他們看到自己的思維方式,越來越封閉,防禦性和無力聽到您的建議就會成為不願接受的收件人。我知道很難看別人周圍的大錯,但不要浪費您的智慧。世界上有很多人想要您的幫助。

是什麼使批評有用

正如我們上週討論的那樣,有用的批評是:

  1. 特定
  2. 建設性
  3. 正面

讓我們以更深入的深度檢查每個。

特定< /strong>
說“我喜歡它!”或“我討厭它!”沒有給藝術家太多。查找圖像的特定區域,這些區域表現出它們擁有的好是壞藝術習慣,並指出這些習慣。即使您有一個特定的問題,只要說“您不使用廣泛的價值觀”對您所說的藝術家也不意味著什麼。也許他們不使用廣泛的價值觀的原因是他們在研究中尚未遇到這個概念。取而代之的是,嘗試說類似的話:“該圖像中的光源看起來來自右側,但是您的鉛筆值在臉部的左側和右側相同。”那裡!現在,您已經確定了一個特定的問題,以及它出現的特定示例,以便學生可以將自己定向到您的意思。

建設性< /strong>
一旦確定了一個特定問題,您將要提供一些有關如何解決問題的特定建議。有時,這個問題將太大,無法在一個回應中掩蓋。在這種情況下,提供一個起點。它可能是特定於圖像的:“嘗試在右側添加亮點,然後在面部左側添加深色陰影。”或者這可能是關於一般技能的,“在下次練習期間,設置檯燈並將其直接指向某些物體,並真正花費一些時間觀察和繪製亮點和陰影。這將有助於您感覺到光線與物體的互動,並幫助您建立信心來使用鉛筆可以產生最黑暗的價值。

正面< /strong>
當我說批評是積極的時,我並不是說這都是讚美。有時,它包括讚美,因為對於藝術家知道自己在做正確的事或表現出改進的地方可能會有所幫助,因此他們可以繼續做有效的事情。但是,一項根本不包含讚美的批評仍然可以是積極的 - 它只需要假設藝術家有能力學習和改進和提高目的,目的是為了幫助,而不是攻擊藝術背後的人。貫穿所有這些要求的總體主題是尊重。

無論您批評的藝術家多麼綠色,無論有多少錯誤,他們都會通過將自己的工作放在那裡,並朝著改進邁出重要一步。給予它應有的尊重,並真正嘗試提供幫助。現在您知道瞭如何提出有用的批評,希望我們能在我們的 Critique Forumss

中看到您提供知識。

評論

Dominique Squire (unregistered visitor)
This is so helpful. Thank you! I appreciate it! :)
SoonJ (unregistered visitor)
This article's very useful! I've done critiques many times, but I don't know how to do properly. Your explain's so simple but valid!
Linda4atc
Hi I joined a Daily Drawing Group and we are supposed to critique work posted. This has been so helpful because I was really afraid that I did not qualify to speak up, now I think I can at least sometimes. LOL Thank you.
Kim - 網站管理員
I'm so glad to hear that this is helpful! Being able to give the gift of critique can help you make a major difference in a student's art practice.
Zacc406
Not everyone is in acceptance of the critique to other artists. Just because someone can draw a fantastic landscape with all of the little things. Doesn't mean they can give a good critque.
What is wrong with this scenario?
Kim - 網站管理員
Being able to give useful critique is a skill like any other. It requires some practice and thought. Thus, articles like this one.

Obviously you should not give feedback to people who are not open to it.
Jonathan Labuga (unregistered visitor)
The article needs appears to have shading on the right, when the light source indicates it should be to its left side..

I kid.

Amazing article, thank you for sharing, now I can be able to give back and receive critiques more confidently :D
Aldo (unregistered visitor)
Cool, keep the great work.
Abcicletta (unregistered visitor)
me too
Bruce Jones
When someone says they like or dislike a piece of my work, I like asking "Why do you think that is?" or "What do you think kicked off that response?" Some people just can't identify what did it, but the ones who can really do help me improve.
Kim - 網站管理員
Excellent tip!
Snow Yeti
That’s actually not a bad idea, ima go try it out thx
Polyvios Animations
I like this article, really.
Astronaut
For an absolute beginner, this is really good. the best tip I have for you is to keep in mind that the head is a sphere with two flat sides ( where the ears are). So your lines that divide the face up should wrap around. Keep practicing and you'll get it!
Echo123 (unregistered visitor)
I don't totally understand English
Ringringring
哈哈,我英语挺糟糕,感谢浏览器自动帮我翻译
XFAFA1415
居然是同道中人
Carlos76
Um grande salve a esta comunidade, pretendo aqui trocar experiências e melhorar o meu trabalho. Não conheço anatomia humana tecnicamente, meu processo é mais intuitivo, e espero encontrar a direção certa em meu trabalho e unir intuição e tecnica. Estou aqui para desenvolver um bom trabalho junto a esta comunidade.
Kanaiyah Ward
nice this will help me in the long run
HeSui
it's really a fantastic website for me to get abundant materials.
金金金 (unregistered visitor)
i feel so lucky that there is a website for me to learn more about drawing and improve my problem so that i can conquer the weakness of mine
Phoebeegeebee
This is so well written! I feel like it’s some kind of pet peeve of mine when someone just says my art is ‘good’ and doesn’t go any further into it. This article puts into words amazingly and I’ll definitely take this advice if and when I critique others work!
Frauke
One think I always try to do when giving feedback is to start and end with positives. So I'd start out with mentioning something I think the artist has done that I really like, then try and give advice on how to improve their work, then end with a general positive comment, like "I am looking forward to seeing your next piece"
葱---2
感觉你画的左肩厚了那么一点点...

有时候你觉得不顺眼的话可以做出那个动作然后照镜子。。。
Futureflash351
Sometimes if you feel something is not pleasing to the eye, you can make that move and then look in the mirror... your welcome for translating
Zacc406
That's very true. 🥺 👈🏻
Polyvios Animations
I still love this article so much, as the last post. Thank you. I appreciate it. We really do.
Angelicdonuts
This is from such a long time ago, but holy moly! It's super helpful and makes so much sense!! I think everyone (at least those willing to take it in) could benefit from reading this. I'll admit that critique was a bit of a tough, uncomfortable subject for me to stomach the idea of. I used to think it was really nothing but people tearing your work apart and leaving you there to figure out what to do with the mangled bits they leave behind, but I can breath a little easier knowing that is *not* how critique works. Thank you!
Kim - 網站管理員
I'm so glad! Yes, it can take a lot of practice to get used to both giving and receiving critiques. They are skills in their own right. But they can be sooo helpful! :)

添加評論

你的電子郵件不會被發布、出售或分發。這只是我們記錄和反垃圾郵件工作的一部分。

作為我們反垃圾郵件工作的一部分,當你發表評論時,我們會記錄你的IP地址。